Determined not to "sell out the trade"
According to artisan Nguyen Thi Muoi, the second-generation representative of a pho brand in Hanoi , her family initially only had one pho business in the Cau Giay area. Despite the large number of customers, due to unforeseen circumstances, the family moved the business to the Hai Ba Trung area. Interestingly, many regular customers still frequent the new location to enjoy their pho, as they are already very familiar with the family's pho flavor.
Based on the established quality and family brand, the Mười family of artisans has expanded to include other establishments in Hanoi. According to artisan Nguyen Thi Mười, someone once offered to buy her family's pho brand at a very high price, but she never considered selling it. She believes that if she becomes old and frail and no longer has the health to continue, she will pass the craft on to her children and grandchildren to preserve the family tradition.

The unique techniques preserved through generations help traditional pho restaurants retain customers.
Fortunately, her son, Tran Huy Tien, 36 years old, is also very passionate about pho. Tien said that because he enjoys business, his family's traditional pho recipe is the foundation that will help him continue developing the business in the future, following in his mother's footsteps. Sharing the secret to retaining loyal customers for many years, Tran Huy Tien confidently asserts that it's the unique family technique passed down through generations.
According to Mr. Tien, the flavor of his family's pho is well-received not because of cinnamon, star anise, or any other special flavoring, but because it comes entirely from the natural broth made from pure beef and bone stock. This natural flavor awakens the senses of many diners when they visit the restaurant. Mr. Tien further shared that, in addition to focusing on economic benefits , the recognition of pho as a national intangible cultural heritage is also a great motivation for business owners like him to be determined to preserve the craft.
In fact, while many families pass down the pho-making tradition through generations, there are also customers who have been loyal to a particular pho restaurant for generations. As a customer, Ms. Nguyen Pham Ngoc Tuan from Hanoi shared that her family has been eating at a pho restaurant on Nguyen Hong Street (formerly Dong Da District) for decades. Before becoming "loyal" to this restaurant, she and her husband and children had tried many other pho restaurants in Hanoi, but they found the one on Nguyen Hong Street to be the most to their liking.
Ms. Nguyen Pham Ngoc Tuan further added that although her daughter is now married and has two grown children, her entire family still frequently returns to this pho restaurant to enjoy a meal together on weekends. Moreover, Ms. Tuan has recommended the restaurant to many friends, and everyone confirms that the pho is as delicious as she advertised.
According to the UNESCO Hanoi Association, some long-standing pho restaurants in the capital not only build reputable brands but also meet the criteria of being neat and clean, attracting a large and stable customer base. These long-standing establishments often have a strong family tradition. Their unique techniques are also the core value that affirms the brand of each family-run pho business.
A brand must be strong and stable before it can go far.
Long-standing pho brands often begin with a family member practicing the trade, then are preserved and developed through generations. According to Dr. Pham Thi Lan Anh, Head of the Heritage Management Department of the Hanoi Department of Culture, Sports and Tourism, for a brand to go far, pho must first survive in its birthplace and be recognized by the local community.
Referring to the saying "good news travels fast," Ms. Pham Thi Lan Anh believes that the reputation of a pho restaurant primarily comes from recommendations from local people. International tourists visiting a region with different culinary habits often trust the recommendations and promotions of the locals. However, she believes that whether an already recognized pho brand can thrive and gain recognition in other locations still requires significant support.
To make a traditional pho restaurant more attractive to customers, Ms. Lan Anh believes that establishments also need to consider changing their service style and space accordingly. She gives the example that to accommodate groups of ten to thirty or forty people, the restaurant needs sufficient seating and parking. If the parking space is too cramped, serving such groups will be difficult.

While many families pass down the pho-making tradition through generations, there are also numerous customers who have been loyal to a particular pho restaurant for generations.
Along with proper space arrangement, establishments also need to recruit and train staff systematically, because one artisan cannot handle all stages of the process. Ms. Lan Anh cited the case of artisan Nguyen Thi Muoi passing on her skills to her son, which is a transfer of knowledge. And knowledge about making pho must be linked to the artisan. From that knowledge, subsequent generations preserve and develop it to create a family brand.
According to Ms. Pham Thi Lan Anh, for a long time, when discussing food management, state management agencies have mainly focused on the market, taxes, and food safety. The culture of the profession, however, is formed through the community's practice and transmission of the craft. She cited the example of traditional craft villages, where the culture of the craft is spontaneously formed and maintained through many generations. From this, she emphasized the necessity of respecting the community, artisans, and those directly practicing the heritage.
Bringing the Vietnamese pho brand to international friends.
According to Ms. Pham Thi Lan Anh, state management agencies can support the promotion of heritage and remove administrative obstacles when organizing activities to promote and introduce heritage domestically and internationally. Cultural events organized by the Hanoi Department of Culture, Sports and Tourism and the Hanoi UNESCO Association are an example. She emphasized that linking heritage promotion with tourism will yield better results.
Ms. Lan Anh believes that building a pho brand in the digital age is not a simple task. Publicly sharing all the skills and secrets of cooking pho in digital form could cause families to lose their unique recipes passed down through generations. Moreover, having the recipe doesn't guarantee you can cook a bowl of pho with the authentic original flavor. She uses herself as an example. Being a less skilled cook, even with the secret recipe from a famous pho restaurant, she would still struggle to cook it as well as the original creator. What needs to be widely promoted is a pho brand with recognized quality.
Mr. Truong Minh Tien, Chairman of the UNESCO Hanoi Association, said that in recent times, in addition to introducing the cultural heritage values of the capital city to the international community and friends, the Association has also carried out activities contributing to bringing the pho heritage to foreign audiences.
Recalling a business trip to attend a food festival in Tokyo, Japan , Mr. Tien said that the organizers had arranged a separate space to showcase many Vietnamese dishes. What surprised and made him proud was that pho was chosen by the Vietnamese delegation as the central dish to be featured at the festival. According to him, if more Vietnamese pho artisans participated, such events would be an opportunity for those in the profession to introduce the pho heritage to the Japanese public and international friends.




