On November 17th, a reporter from Tien Phong newspaper observed that along Pham Van Dong street in Bac Nha Trang ward, Khanh Hoa province, workers were continuing to dismantle the old railings along the coastline to begin construction of new ones.

This move comes after the People's Committee of Khanh Hoa province issued a document requesting the Provincial Development Project Management Board (the investor) to continue constructing the railing system along Pham Van Dong road, part of the Nha Trang riverbank and coastal railing upgrade project, according to the approved design.
According to the People's Committee of Khanh Hoa province, the investor's proposal to adjust the design with the aim of enhancing urban aesthetics lacks sufficient grounds for implementation.
Earlier, in early November, the leaders of the Khanh Hoa Provincial People's Committee requested the Provincial Development Project Management Board to inspect and review the entire project proposal process and the design of its components; and at the same time, assess the extent to which the project meets urban aesthetic requirements.

Following a review, the investor proposed three design modifications to enhance aesthetics. However, after consideration, the People's Committee of Khanh Hoa province found that these options lacked sufficient basis for implementation. Therefore, the province requested the investor to continue construction according to the approved design.
The old railing system along the Phạm Văn Đồng coastal road was built more than 10 years ago. Over time, due to use and direct exposure to the marine environment, the structure has deteriorated, with some areas of concrete peeling off, exposing rusted steel reinforcement, posing a potential safety risk.

In June 2021, the People's Committee of Nha Trang City (formerly) approved the investment plan for the project to upgrade riverbank and coastal railings, including the section along Pham Van Dong Street. The project aims to replace, reinforce, and beautify the railing system along coastal and riverbank roads in the city.
However, the project's implementation was subsequently interrupted for various reasons. After the two-tiered local government model came into operation, the project was assigned to the Khanh Hoa Provincial Development Project Management Board as the investor.
As the new railing system gradually took shape, the project received mixed reactions from residents. Many opinions suggested that the new design was not aesthetically pleasing, appearing somewhat crude and heavy, and not befitting the landscape of the Nha Trang bay area. "Nha Trang needs a seawall with character, not just a concrete wall separating the land from the sea," shared Mr. Truong, a resident of Nha Trang ward.

Some other residents believe that the old railing design still has its own unique beauty. Although the structure is dilapidated, renovation, reinforcement, and repair could be a worthwhile option instead of completely rebuilding. "I think leaving the old railings as they are looks more aesthetically pleasing and sturdy. Especially, they have more character than the newly built ones. Nearly 14 billion VND for a project that, in my opinion, isn't really necessary," said Ms. Quyen, a resident of Bac Nha Trang ward.
There are also opinions that replacement is necessary because the old system has corroded and been damaged by the effects of seawater, and no longer ensures safety. Mr. Nang, a resident of Bac Nha Trang ward, said that in recent days, the story of building nearly 2km of railings along Pham Van Dong road, from Hon Chong to Ba Lang, has attracted the attention of many people.

According to Mr. Nang, looking back at the entire process from the old railings, the construction phase, to the completion of the new structure, each option has its own advantages and disadvantages. Mr. Nang explained that the old railing system was built in an area that is a reclaimed land road, with a narrow beach, and is frequently subjected to sea waves. Over the years, saltwater seeped into the structure, causing the steel core to corrode and the concrete to crumble. Therefore, replacing it to ensure safety was the logical solution.
However, Mr. Nang also noted that although the new railing system is larger and more robust, its rather thick design creates a cramped feeling and somewhat restricts the view of the bay, especially for those inside cars.




